Detective Snoopy holds a magnifying glass alongside Woodstock and the Peanuts gang.

Snoopy Game Publisher Reaches Settlement Over Peanuts Music

The publisher of “Snoopy & The Great Mystery Club” has reached a settlement in principle over allegations that its soundtrack copied Vince Guaraldi’s “Linus and Lucy” and “Skating.” The dispute centered on a distinction familiar to music licensing: permission to use the characters did not include permission to use their music.

Lee Mendelson Film Productions, which holds the copyrights to the two compositions, sued GameMill Entertainment in May. The settlement’s financial terms have not been publicly disclosed.

A dismissal order filed Nov. 9 states that the parties reported reaching a settlement in principle. U.S. District Judge Denise Cote allowed either side to request that the case be restored to the court’s calendar by Dec. 7. Without such a request, the dismissal becomes final.

What the Snoopy Game Music Lawsuit Alleged

According to the complaint, GameMill licensed the Peanuts characters from Peanuts Worldwide but did not obtain a license for the Guaraldi compositions. Instead, Lee Mendelson Film Productions alleged, the publisher hired others to create similar music for the game.

The claim concerned newly composed recordings that allegedly copied protected elements of Guaraldi’s work. It was not simply an accusation that GameMill had put the original recordings into its soundtrack.

To support its case, the production company commissioned an analysis from musicologist Ethan Lustig. Working from a 4½-hour video walkthrough, he identified strong similarities to one or both Guaraldi compositions in 15 of the game’s 17 distinct musical cues, according to the complaint.

Those 15 cues occupied 89.6% of the walkthrough. That figure describes the video Lustig examined, rather than every possible playthrough of the game.

The complaint also singled out music played when a player successfully completed a task or challenge. It alleged that these success cues drew on “Linus and Lucy,” tying the disputed musical passages to the game’s rewards.

A Settlement Without an Infringement Ruling

The allegations and commissioned analysis represent the production company’s case. They are not findings by the court, and the dismissal order does not decide whether GameMill infringed the copyrights.

The distinction between the characters and compositions remains central to understanding the dispute. Peanuts Worldwide controls the characters, while Lee Mendelson Film Productions holds the rights asserted in this lawsuit. Peanuts Worldwide was not a party to the case.

The settlement leaves the infringement claims unresolved by a judge. Its undisclosed terms also leave unanswered whether GameMill will pay damages, license the compositions or change the game’s soundtrack.